Entry 10: Europe’s Climate Regulation Crossroads: A Fragmented Future for Business

Europe is at a crossroads in climate and sustainability policy. As Brussels attempts to streamline sustainability reporting through its Omnibus package, Madrid is charting a more ambitious course. The result is a regulatory landscape that is increasingly fragmented, multi-speed, and fraught with both opportunity and risk for European businesses.

It also represents the geographic split within the EU between the climate and drought-hit south and the north. This divergence between EU-level and national regulation signals a new era of climate governance: multi-speed, multi-layered, and increasingly complex.

Recalibration of ambition

The European Commission’s Omnibus proposal, unveiled earlier this year, is a recalibration of the EU’s sustainability ambitions. It aims to reduce the administrative burden of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), and the EU Taxonomy Regulation.

Postponement but not dropped

The headline changes include a two-year postponement of reporting deadlines for second- and third-wave companies, a narrowing of the scope to only the largest firms (those with over 1,000 employees and €50 million in turnover), and a 25–35% reduction in required data points.

The rationale is clear: competitiveness. The Draghi report and the Competitiveness Compass both warned that Europe’s green ambitions risked becoming a bureaucratic drag. The Commission responded with a package expected to save €6.3 billion annually and unlock €50 billion in sustainable investment. Again, the EU fail to focus on the middle market and SMES who will drive the transition and real changes.

Yet, while Brussels lowers the floor, Spain is raising the ceiling.

In a bold move, the Spanish government has enacted Royal Decree 214/2025 and launched a sweeping Climate Emergency Plan. Effective from June 2025, the decree mandates carbon reporting for large companies and public institutions, with Scope 1 and 2 emissions due in 2026 (based on 2025 data), and Scope 3 phased in from 2028. Businesses must also submit five-year greenhouse gas reduction plans and prepare for stricter land-use and forest management rules. A new national agency for civil protection has been established to coordinate climate resilience efforts.

Spain’s approach is not merely regulatory—it is strategic. The country is investing €32 billion in clean energy, targeting 100% renewable electricity by 2050 and 81% by 2030. Already, over half of Spain’s electricity comes from renewables. While the anti-carbon and climate lobby attributed the April 2025 power outage to the failure of renewables, the real reason was far more prosaic. The government report says some conventional power plants—those burning coal, gas, or nuclear—failed to do their bit, letting voltage levels spike and triggering a domino effect of shutdowns across the network

The Compliance Conundrum

For businesses operating across borders, the implications are profound. The Omnibus package simplifies compliance for many firms, but only within the EU’s baseline. Member states like Spain are asserting their sovereignty, layering additional obligations atop EU directives. The result is a patchwork of rules that vary not only by sector and size but also by geography.

This fragmentation creates a compliance nightmare for multinational corporations. Reporting frameworks must now accommodate both EU-wide standards and country-specific mandates. For example, a company headquartered in Germany but operating in Spain must reconcile the relaxed CSRD thresholds with Spain’s mandatory Scope 3 reporting and resilience planning.

Moreover, the EU’s decision to delay sector-specific standards and reasonable assurance requirements under the CSRD removes clarity just as national governments are demanding more. The risk is that companies will face overlapping, inconsistent, and potentially contradictory obligations.

Strategic Implications for Business

Yet, within this complexity lies opportunity. Spain’s aggressive stance may serve as a blueprint for climate leadership. By embedding ESG compliance into its economic strategy, Spain is positioning itself as Europe’s clean energy powerhouse. Companies that align early with these higher standards may gain a competitive edge in capital markets, supply chains, and consumer trust.

The shift also underscores the growing importance of Scope 3 emissions. For most firms, these account for the bulk of their carbon footprint. Spain’s decision to mandate Scope 3 reporting from 2028 forces companies to engage deeply with their value chains—mapping emissions, collaborating with suppliers, and investing in data infrastructure.

This is not just a reporting exercise; it is a transformation of corporate strategy. ESG is no longer a peripheral concern—it is central to risk management, investor relations, and operational resilience.

A Call for Coherence

The EU’s Omnibus package is a pragmatic response to business concerns. But it risks sending mixed signals. By easing requirements, Brussels may inadvertently undermine the Green Deal’s credibility and Europe’s global leadership in sustainability. Meanwhile, Spain’s assertiveness shows that ambition and competitiveness are not mutually exclusive.

What is needed now is coherence. The EU must ensure that its simplification agenda does not devolve into deregulation. Member states must coordinate to avoid regulatory whiplash. And businesses must invest in systems that can adapt to evolving standards, both EU-wide and national.

The emergence of a multi-speed Europe is not inherently problematic. Diversity can foster innovation. But without harmonisation, it risks inefficiency, confusion, and reduced impact.

Conclusion

Europe stands at a crossroads. The Omnibus package offers relief to businesses burdened by ESG compliance. Spain’s Climate Emergency Plan offers a vision of climate leadership rooted in legal obligation and economic transformation.

For companies, the message is clear: prepare for complexity. The regulatory landscape will not be uniform. Success will depend on agility, foresight, and a willingness to go beyond the minimum. The EU sets the floor. Spain—and perhaps others—are setting the ceiling. The question for business is not whether to comply, but how high to aim.

Ends

About Martello

In a fast-paced and dynamic world, our value proposition is rooted in our calm, delivery-focused mindset, attention to detail, and the ability to understand and provide context that supports our clients in navigating their day-to-day challenges.

Our services include strategy, communication, capital markets, investor relations, carbon and sustainability.

As consultants, we work with companies, investors, and organisations in Bristol, London, Dublin and globally.

Book a meeting to start a conversation about how we can support your business today.

https://www.martello.works/contact